| Hymnal Number | Title | Tune name | Sacred Harp | Tune name | Note |
|---|
| 8 | Brethren, we have met to worship | Holy Manna | 59 | Holy Manna | |
| | | | | |
| 39 | Lord of the worlds above | Lenox | 40 | Lenox | |
| 42 | All people that on earth do dwell | Old Hundredth | 49 t | Old Hundred | |
| 54 | Praise the Lord who reigns above | Amesterdam | 84 | Amsterdam | |
| 81 | Oh, for a thousand tongues to sing | Lyngham | 350 | Nativity | |
| 106 | All hail the power of Jesus's name | Corontation | 63 | Coronation | |
| 137 | Forgive our sins as we forgive | Detroit | 39 t | Detroit | |
| 139 | Far, far away from my loving father | Restoration (I will arise) | 312 b | Restoration | |
| 143 | Amazing grace! | New Britain (Amazing Grace) | 45 t | New Britain | |
| 212 | O Come, all ye faithful | Adeste Fideles | 223 | Portuguese Hymn | |
| 253 | Alas! And did my Savior bleed? | Martyrdom | 569 b | Sacred Throne | |
| 277 | I know that my Redeemer lives | Shout on, Pray on | 277 | Antioch | Same page number! |
| 285 | All hail the power of Jesus's name | Diadem | 198 | Green Street | Sacred Harp tune is based on Diadem |
| 363 | Renew your church | All is Well | 122 | All is Well | Significantly different tune |
| 369 | Lord, whose love in humble service | Beach Spring | 81 t | Beach Spring | |
| 393 | A charge to keep I have | Boylston | 147 t | Boylston | |
| 414 | God, who stretched | Holy Manna | 59 | Holy Manna | |
| 417 | All who love and serve your city | Charlestown | 52 b | Charlestown |
| 425 | Come, come ye saints | All is Well | 122 | All is Well | Significantly different tune |
| 457 | Be present at our table, Lord | Old Hundredth | 47 t | Old Hundred | |
| 503 | Come, O thou Traveler unknown | Vernon | 95 | Vernon | |
| 530 | What wondrous love is this | Wondrous Love | 159 | Wondrous Love | |
| 536 | Take up your cross | Kedron | 48 b | Kedron | |
| 547 | My dear Redeemer and my Lord | Social Band | 42 | Clamanda | |
| 560 | In lonely mountain ways | Golden Hill | 195 | Worchester | Davisson published defuged version of Worchester in 1816, named it Golden Hill |
| 567 | How firm a foundation | Foundation (Bellevue) | 72 b | Bellevue | |
| 600 | O bless the Lord, my soul | St Thomas (Williams) | 34 b | St Thomas | |
| 610 | On Jordan's stormy bank I stand | Bound for the promised land | 128 | The promised land | |
| 618 | This is the day the Lord has made | Arlington | 73 b | Arlington | |
| Hymnals Number | Title | Tune name | Notes |
|---|
| 49 | From all that dwell below the skies | Duke Street |
| 72 | When all they mercies, O my God | Geneva |
| 118 | Praise God from Whom | Dedication Anthem (606) | Harmonia Sacra |
| 126 | How wondrous great | Awful Majesty | Dunlap's Creek; renamed in Harmonia Sacra |
| 212 | Hail the bless'd morn | Star in the East | From Southern Harmony |
| 234 | When Jesus wept, the falling tear | When Jesus Wept | Billings |
| 184 | Hark! The glad sound | Communion | First published in Wyeth, Part Second |
| 244 | Alone thou goest forth | Bangor | Included in Easy Instructor |
| 284 | Exultation | Exultation | First published in Davisson's Supplement to the Kentucky Harmony, 1820 |
| 361 | O Spirit of the Living God | Plainfield | First published in shapes by Wyeth |
| 373 | Thou true Vine, that heals | Pleading Savior | Included in Southern Harmony |
| 433 | Go, my children | Ar Hyd y Nos | Welsh tune, included as 'Welch' in Southern Harmony |
| 459 | I will come with joy to meet my Lord | Dove of Peace | Included in Southern Harmony |
| 387 | Lord, thou dost love | Pleading Savior | Included in Southern Harmony |
| 509 | The tree of life | Apple Tree | Based on Ingalls' original, 1805 |
| 521 | Come, thou fount | Nettleton | First published in Wyeth, 1813 |
| 556 | Lord, thou hast searched me | Tender Thought | |
| 589 | My Shepherd will supply my need | Resignation |
| 597 | Oh, how happy are they | New Concord | First published in shapes in 1825 by Davisson |
| 615 | Shall we gather at the river | Beautiful River | 449 in Cooper Book |